Letter: Nothing scenic about cell towers

In 1962, forward-thinking leaders in Rappahannock County adopted a zoning ordinance that would help protect the scenic and rural aspects of this county. Landowners throughout the county voluntarily down-zoned their properties to protect the county from being suburbanized. Since then, private landowners have voluntarily protected more than 28,500 acres of land through voluntary conservation easements that protect the scenic nature of the county. Our Comprehensive Plan sums up this intense passion by stating that “we the people of Rappahannock declare it to be a ‘scenic county’ and all goals, principles, and policies will reflect and devolve from this fundamental recognition.”

Now AT&T wants to put a 199-foot monopole at the high school that would be seen by everyone who drives down U.S. 211, a scenic byway, whether on their way to the mountains on vacation or on their way home from work. Look up to catch that hard-won, beautiful mountain view and behold, a nearly 200-foot pole lofting ahead, complete with up to 48 six-foot antennae attached.

The current AT&T applications for cell facilities in the county are completely out of character with everything the county has declared important in our Comprehensive Plan and flatly ignores all the hard work citizens have put into conserving a community that does not look like Anywhere, U.S.A. The applications pay no heed to concerns based on the scenic character of the county despite the ordinance that lists “minimizing the adverse effects of community and the land” as a stated purpose when regulating such facilities.

The applicant ignores specific sections of the ordinance that require mitigating the effects to residents, scenic byways, highways, and historic districts. In fact, AT&T does not even acknowledge in the applications that these resources exist.

There is no reason that cell phone service needs to be synonymous with 199-foot structures. Sprint is currently using a series of shorter towers to serve the area between the high school and Amissville. AT&T could provide coverage by co-locating on these facilities at their existing, or near existing, heights. Instead they are proposing a 199-foot monopole at the high school, as well as extending the currently hidden Grimsley tower across from the old e-cow location from its current height at 80 feet to a considerably taller 144 feet. Meanwhile, all over the commonwealth, cell providers are installing shorter monopoles, utilizing existing buildings and providing cell service without installing 200-foot monoliths.

Far from this being a badge of honor for entering the 21st century, the current plan, if adopted, signals turning back the clock on scenic protections in the county, and would set a dangerous precedent in which the Planning Commission and the Board of Supervisors ignore the intent of the Comprehensive Plan and fail to enforce sections of their own zoning ordinance.

Call your planning commissioner and supervisor today to tell them to deny these applications that would needlessly relinquish our hard-fought gains in scenic protection. There are multiple options for cell sites and designs that would respect both the desire for cell service and the desire to remain a scenic county.

Don Loock
Land Conservation Officer
Piedmont Environmental Council

Staff/Contributed
About Staff/Contributed 4349 Articles
The Rappahannock News welcomes contributions from any and all members of the community. Email news and photos to editor@rappnews.com or call us at 540-675-3338.

1 Comment

  1. Many thanks to Don Loock for so eloquently stating the obvious feeling of a majority of long-time Rappahannock residents who have vigilantly protected the unique scenic status of this remarkable community for generations. What has already happened in this process is shocking to me, and if this sham continues uncontested, it will forever change what so many have worked for so long to prevent.

    The Planning Commission and the Supervisors should slow these deliberations and allow a fuller, more studied analysis and debate on this matter. AT&T’s proposals will forever change the character of our beloved county, and that change must be one that has the understanding and support of the citizenry. So far, this plan has only caused deep division and very real resentment. And that is not the “Rappahannock way,” either.

    Let’s put the brakes on this while we still have what we have worked for these many years.

    Ben Jones

Comments are closed.